|
At the close of last year,
the media was filled with front-page stories
trumpeting the fact that charitable giving in
the wake of Hurricane Katrina had surpassed
giving following both the Asian Tsunami and the
terrorist attacks of 9/11. Yesterday, Harwood
Institute President Richard C. Harwood shared
his views on this news with law-makers and
non-profit executives gathered for the Maryland
Association of Nonprofit Organizations
Legislative Preview Session. “It confirms for
me again,” said Harwood, “that Americans
are a compassionate and generous people, and if
they see a way to make a difference, they will
act.”
But there is more to
finding an alternate path than charity. Harwood
continued, “Charity is necessary, but not
sufficient to meet the challenges we face in
our communities and across the nation. We need
change. We need change to ensure that every
child can get a good education, to ensure that
every individual feels safe when he walks the
streets of his community, and to fight hatred,
bigotry and prejudice in our society.”
In nearly two decades of
working in communities around the country,
Harwood has seen first-hand what it takes to
create change in communities from Flint,
Michigan, to Las Vegas, Nevada. During his
15-city tour promoting his book Hope
Unraveled last fall, he saw time and again
that we need to focus on change, not simply
charity.
Ironically, one such
couragous example was herself named Katrina,
known to those in her “Pittsburgh”
neighborhood in Atlanta as Miss Trina. Miss
Trina had originally been driven from her
neighborhood by the noise and danger emanating
from two crack houses on her block. She
re-settled with her family in a middle class
neighborhood removed from Pittsburgh in both
geography and public conscious, but she could
not shake the feeling that she had left others
behind.
Not content to sit on the
sidelines, Miss Trina moved back to a house
near the old Pittsburgh neighborhood to
confront the crack houses and hopelessness of
the community head on. In her role with the
Salvation Army, she is leading an effort to
build a new neighborhood community center. Such
a gathering space is a vital part of a
community, but it will only be a force for
change if people like Miss Trina devote
themselves over the long run to using the
community center as a catalyst for change. If
such efforts are not undertaken, there would be
only an empty shell of a building to show for
the charity that went into its construction.
Unlike the ripples of hope
generated by the work of Miss Trina, Hurricane
Katrina left a path of destruction across the
gulf coast region that will take years to
rebuild. The charity is there, but the question
remains, will there be change? Change will not
be easy, and it will not be seen overnight. We
must be ruthlessly strategic in our efforts,
examining our own sensibilities and practices,
and admitting that we must often change
ourselves before we can create change in a
community. Some questions to consider as we
struggle to move forward:
- Will we be willing to confront the issues
of poverty and race that caused so many people
to be left behind as a great American city
filled with toxic water?
- Will we invest in the kinds of individuals
and organizations that can cut across class,
race, and geography and generate the small
signs of progress that foster authentic hope?
- Will we be willing to openly and honestly
discuss the values and tradeoffs inherent in
the difficult choices that must be made in the
months and years ahead?
For all the uncertainty
that we face as a nation, this is certain: If
we are ever to recover from the effects of the
Katrina of the Gulf Coast, we will need to look
beyond charity and find stories of hope in the
work of people like Miss Trina of Atlanta to
create change. |