Have you answered Jon Stewart yet?
Posted by
Rich Harwood
Aug 19, 2008
Redeeming Hope by Rich Harwood. A blog
about making good on your urge to do good, and
about imagining and acting for the public
good.

Last night my wife handed me a
Sunday
New York Times article
on Jon Stewart --
Is
this the Most Trusted
Man in America? -- telling me that I
had to read it. She was right. You
should, too. During a time of record-breaking
Olympics, a decidedly mixed
presidential race, and general social anxiety,
Jon Stewart's success on "The
Daily Show" holds some key insights for those
of us who want to make good on
our urge to do good.
For me, there are at least three components to
Stewart's success:
1. He
and his staff display an uncanny ability to
puncture false realities, a great
gift at a time when so many people feel that
their realities are being actively
distorted in public life and politics.
2. He
consistently shines a bright line on a range of
issues the mainstream news
media often handle with kid gloves or ignore,
such as the war in Iraq, the
aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, the
politicization of the Department of
Justice, and more.
3. Stewart
is able to make his points through a
combination of satire, humor, profane
language, and a host of other techniques, all
strategically deployed to engage
viewers.
Now, think about Stewart in
relationship to the current
presidential race, which increasingly seems to
be teetering on the brink of another
battle over false realities and empty hope.
Recent campaign ads are riddled
with half-truths, negativity, and silly efforts
to misdirect conversation away
from people's genuine concerns. I suppose the
upcoming party conventions will
be relatively better -- could they be any worse
-- but how long that improvement will
last before the campaigns again descend into a
debate over false realities is
anyone's guess. All this from two candidates
many of us expected would produce
a genuine debate and sense of possibility about
our future.
Juxtapose these candidates to another
group of high-profile
individuals, the current U.S. Olympic men's
basketball team: Just four years
ago, this team was essentially booed off the

international stage, as
individuals
who had ignored or rejected any notion of what
it means to act as a team, play
defense, and wear the red, white, and blue.
They lived in the false realities
of self-centeredness, seeming to celebrate the
ugliness of professional
basketball here at home. But this year, U.S.
co-captain Lebron James, who
played on that 2004 team, came together with
new teammates and punctured the
2004 reality. If nothing else, they have proven
that it is possible take a
different path -- if the desire is there.
Listen to these guys being
interviewed, watch them play, and it's so clear
that this is a stand-up group,
proud to wear the USA uniform, humble in their
pronouncements.
So what does all this
mean for you and me? After all,
there's only one Jon Stewart and Lebron James.
None of us have their platforms,
megaphone, or talent. What can we do?
Here are some takeaways for you to
consider:
- You can puncture false
or negative realities when
you decide to step forward and genuinely
attempt to portray life as it really
is. Indeed, it is possible to break through the
noise. For you, this
breakthrough may come in a particular meeting,
or in how you write a brochure,
or produce a new Web site; it may come in how
you structure a new initiative or
program, or in the ways in which you talk about
the challenges you seek to take
on. But be clear, it is these breakthroughs in
how we depict reality that people
are yearning for today.
-
In your attempts to puncture false reality and
shine a light on real issues, you must not
disingenuously straddle the fence. Simply
going through the motions will not do; nor will
rooting your work in reality
only when it is easy or convenient. To do is to
become irrelevant. People
eventually will turn away. Only look at
people's reaction to mainstream news,
the current dynamics of the presidential race,
or local organizations that give
lip service to reality and its real-life
implications. People's "BS-meter" is
very sensitive; they know when they're being
manipulated and toyed with.
-
You must creatively make use of different ways
to engage people in discussions about reality
and its implications. Simply
being "serious" all the time, or projecting
"doom and gloom" won't cut it. You
will need to engage people based on a clear
understanding of your own talents to
engage others and the level of credibility you
hold with people. So, the U.S.
basketball team has gone the route of using
honor, humility, and hard work;
their efforts are a reflection of keen
earnestness and an understated posture.
Jon Stewart mixes in humor, satire, and other
techniques. In today's world of
disbelief, irony, and dissonance, how will you
productively engage people and help
to meet their deep yearning for authentic hope?
So, the bottom line is this: we face
a choice today, which Jon
Stewart, the presidential candidates, and the
U.S. basketball team only serve
to underscore. It is a choice that existed
long before they came along, and it will
persist in our lives no matter what
they do. Will we step forward to do what is
necessary to puncture false
realities and engage people in real ways; or,
will we toy around at the edges, boasting
of a new direction, only to stay within the
boundaries of the same old game?
The second option is safe; but only the first
one allows us to make good on our
urge to do good.